4 Games Like Fears to Fathom in 2026

Psychological horror as a genre of games enjoys some wild popularity. It feels like everyone likes these games except me. But that didn't stop me, I put together games similar to Fears to Fathom anyway, focusing on the ratings of the players.

4 Games Like Fears to Fathom For PC (Steam, EGS, GOG)

4. Firewatch

similar games to Firewatch

Buy: Steam
Metascore: 81
Similarity: 20 %
Year of release: 2016
Game play time: 40 hours
Genre: Adventure
Singleplayer: yes
Coop: no
Multiplayer: no
Trailer: Youtube
Reviews: Metacritic
Review: IGN

Firewatch is a single-player first-person mystery game set in the forests of Wyoming.

3. Mouthwashing

Buy: Steam
Metascore: 88
Similarity: 70 %
Year of release: 2024
Game play time: 3 hours
Genre: Psychological horror
Singleplayer: yes
Coop: no
Multiplayer: no
Trailer: Youtube
Reviews: Metacritic
Review: IGN

The five crew members of the Tulpar are stranded in the empty reaches of space, shrouded in perpetual sunset. God is not watching.

2. No, I’m Not a Human

similar games to No, I’m Not a Human

Buy: Steam
Metascore: 76
Similarity: 70 %
Year of release: 2025
Game play time: 5 hours
Genre: Psychological horror
Singleplayer: yes
Coop: no
Multiplayer: no
Trailer: Youtube
Reviews: Metacritic

WARNING. Stay inside. Lock your doors. Close the blinds. Only let humans in. Eliminate all Visitors. An anxiety horror about paranoia in the End of Times.